Buying guide for best Xbox One controllers
It may be surprising, but the best Xbox controller for most gamers is actually the standard Xbox Core Controller that comes with the console. While it might lack the bells and whistles of some premium options, it offers a comfortable, familiar design perfected over four generations of Xbox controllers. Plus, it boasts a great D-pad, responsive buttons and solid build quality. It even connects wirelessly with low latency. And if you want to avoid batteries altogether, it can be plugged in via USB-C.
Some players want something more than a standard controller. Whether you’re into racing, RPG, fighting, adventure, platformers or first-person shooters, there is a controller out there to enhance your gaming experience. Some controllers let you remap buttons, while others prioritize a comfortable ergonomic design to prevent fatigue during marathon gaming sessions.
To help you pick the right controller, the BestReviews Testing Lab tested and researched the top options. In our comparison, we included wireless controllers with long battery life for extended gaming sessions and wired options for players who prefer a reliable connection and don't want to worry about swapping or charging batteries. To fit the needs and budgets of every gamer, we included controllers across a range of price points.
Our top picks
Microsoft Xbox Core Wireless Controller
Best of the best
Product Specifications
Wireless: Yes | Weight: 9.7 oz | Mappable Buttons: Yes
The Microsoft Xbox Core Wireless Controller, included with every Xbox Series S/X console, feels familiar yet improved. Building on the Xbox One design, it boasts a more comfortable grip, textured triggers for better control and a new share button for capturing gameplay moments. We tested the Core Controller thoroughly and found it to be the best overall choice for most gamers thanks to its versatility and comfortable design.
Our testers evaluated the controller's design, size, weight and button layout. At 9.7 ounces, it feels comfortable in most hands. The button layout retains the successful formula from the Xbox 360, making it instantly familiar for longtime Xbox users. Additionally, the buttons provide a satisfying click with each press, ensuring responsive gameplay. Gamers can even customize their functions for a personalized experience. The wireless connection remained stable throughout testing, and testers reported no discomfort, even after extended three-hour gaming sessions.
Given the dozens of third-party controller options, you may be surprised we're recommending the one that came with your Xbox above the others. Simply put, the Core Wireless controller is a fantastic all-around gamepad that proves to be an excellent choice for gamers of all levels. It offers versatility, a comfortable design, a 40-hour battery life and a great value. What more could a gamer want?
GameSir G7 SE Wired Controller
Best bang for the buck
Product Specifications
Wireless: No | Weight: 18.8 oz | Mappable Buttons: Yes
The GameSir G7 SE Wired Controller offers excellent value for gamers on a budget, but it has something that sets it apart from controllers that cost four times as much.
This wired controller is one of the few that boasts “Hall Effect” joysticks. They use magnetic fields to reduce wear and tear, improve accuracy and minimize the risk of stick drift. Thanks to remappable buttons and user profiles, the controller makes it easy to create custom controller configurations to suit your unique playing style. You can even tweak haptic feedback — a rarity for controllers this cheap.
While wired, the G7 SE offers a comfortable ergonomic grip for extended gaming sessions. If you don’t mind sacrificing the wireless capabilities other Xbox controllers offer, this is a terrific option to consider given its under-$50 price. It’s easy to set up, and we expect it to provide long-lasting performance for years to come.
Microsoft Elite Series 2 Wireless Controller
Best premium Xbox controller
Product Specifications
Wireless: Yes | Weight: 12.16 oz | Mappable Buttons: Yes
The Microsoft Elite Series 2 Wireless Controller is the Cadillac of Xbox controllers. It boasts phenomenal build quality with a substantial weight, reflecting its premium materials. While it retains the familiar Xbox Core Wireless Controller base design, this controller caters more to hardcore gamers by offering a wealth of customizable features.
The interchangeable components and exclusive button-mapping options provide unlimited customizations so you can play your games optimally, and you can save up to three button profiles and toggle between them on the fly. The tension thumbsticks offer excellent accuracy, and the wraparound rubberized grip makes longer gaming sessions more manageable. The rechargeable battery lasts up to 40 hours on a full charge, and you’ll get several accessories, including thumbstick grips, four paddles and two sets of D-pads.
It’s an expensive controller, but its durability and performance make it second to none. The only reason it didn’t notch the top spot is its high price point. However, for hardcore gamers who want a sturdy wireless control with plenty of customization options, the Microsoft Elite Series 2 Wireless Controller is absolutely worth a look.
Razer Wolverine V2 Chroma
Best wired pro controller
Product Specifications
Wireless: No | Weight: 9.52 oz | Mappable Buttons: Yes
If you want a wired controller with plenty of customization, the Razer Wolverine V2 Chroma is a worthy choice. Its 3-million-tap life cycle gives it outstanding durability, and each button is fine-tuned for superior accuracy.
This controller prioritizes speed with an incredibly low actuation time of just 10 milliseconds and a reduced actuation distance that's 35% less than standard controllers. Translation? Minimal input lag for lightning-fast reactions in your games — giving you a competitive edge! Not only that, but the Wolverine V2 Chroma also features four extra triggers, two remappable bumpers and some extra thumbstick caps to suit your unique preferences and playing style. You can even toggle two slide locks to reduce the travel distance of the primary triggers for rapid fire in fast-paced shooters and fighting games.
Bottom line: The Razer is designed for competitive gamers who prioritize performance and customization. While the lack of wireless functionality might be a drawback for some, it shines for its comfortable ergonomic design and premium build quality. Button mapping and responsiveness are excellent, as well, ensuring smooth and accurate gameplay. If you value performance and customization over wireless connectivity, you won't be disappointed.
PowerA Wired Controller for Xbox Series X|S
Best cheap controller
Product Specifications
Wireless: No | Weight: 7.41 oz | Mappable Buttons: No
The PowerA Wired controller is a minimalist option compatible with the Xbox Series X and S consoles. Dual rumble motors provide immersive haptic feedback, allowing you to feel the action in your hands. The wired connection offers a stable connection without the need for batteries or recharging so you can focus on uninterrupted gaming.
Immersive impulse triggers have built-in motors for increased responsiveness, and the headphone jack allows you to use compatible headsets for in-game communication. The precision-tuned analog sticks and anti-friction rings for superior controls facilitate superior accuracy and speed.
We can't recommend the PowerA enough for those in search of a reliable and affordable controller. But if you want more features like RGB lighting, three-way trigger locks and mappable buttons, check out the PowerA Advantage Wired controller, which is priced between the PowerA Wired Controller and the PowerA Fusion Pro 3.
PowerA Fusion Pro 3
Best for shooters
Product Specifications
Wireless: Yes | Weight: 8.46 oz | Mappable Buttons: Yes
For Xbox shooters like Call of Duty, Halo or Rainbow Six, a controller that prioritizes comfort, speed and precision is key. The PowerA Fusion Pro 3 delivers on all fronts. Four programmable buttons let you customize controls to suit your playstyle, while impulse triggers provide realistic haptic feedback that immerses you in the action.
It has an ergonomic design with textured rubber grips and anti-friction rings to reduce fatigue, and you can choose from short and tall analog sticks. Three-way trigger locks allow you to set the distance the trigger buttons travel, enabling quicker firing and giving you a competitive edge. If you primarily play shooters or games that require you to press trigger buttons quickly, you’ll wish you had invested in one sooner.
Turtle Beach Stealth Ultra Wireless
Best third-party controller
Product Specifications
Wireless: Yes | Weight: 13.28 oz | Mappable Buttons: Yes
Forget the usual compromises of third-party controllers. The Turtle Beach Stealth Ultra Wireless Controller delivers high-end design, elite performance and features that surpass even the priciest stock Xbox options.
Its most notable feature is its innovative full-color Connected Command Display dashboard that lets you stay connected while gaming and offers extensive settings adjustments. That means you can receive social media notifications from your phone, so you never have to look away from the action. The battery lasts up to 30 hours, and you can save up to 10 customized button-mapping profiles. It also boasts anti-drift thumbsticks for improved control and RGB lights you can personalize.
The command display alone makes this controller stand apart from the rest, but there’s plenty to love about it. It’s an expensive controller, but for avid gamers, it’s worth a look. Plus, it’s available in eight stylish colors to match your battle station.
SCUF Instinct Pro Performance Series Wireless Xbox Controller
Best customizable controller
Product Specifications
Wireless: Yes | Weight: 9.5 oz | Mappable Buttons: Yes
The SCUF Instinct Pro Performance Series Wireless Xbox Controller prioritizes elite performance without sacrificing aesthetics. While it's pricier than other options, it retains the sleek design of the original Xbox controller and is completely wireless, unlike some bulkier third-party controllers. This combination of premium feel and top-notch performance makes it a compelling choice for serious gamers. It even remembers three of your favorite configurations, so switching between games or playstyles is a breeze. Additionally, interchangeable thumbsticks allow you to find the right fit.
The SCUF Instinct Pro goes beyond standard button mapping with four paddles configurable for up to a whopping 15 functions each. This opens up a world of personalized control options, allowing you to tailor your controller for different games. It's a fantastic choice for gamers who enjoy a variety of genres and want to switch button layouts quickly without tinkering with settings in each game. Another perk: It has a nonslip grip to keep even the sweatiest of palms secure and stable.
Microsoft Xbox Adaptive Controller
Best for those with limited mobility
Product Specifications
Wireless: Yes | Weight: 1.21 lb | Mappable Buttons: Yes
Gaming should be accessible and enjoyable for everyone. However, for players with limitations in hand and arm mobility, a standard Xbox controller can be uncomfortable or even painful to use for extended periods. Microsoft addressed this challenge by creating an innovative solution: the Adaptive Controller. We tip our hat to Microsoft for designing a product that prioritizes comfort and inclusivity so more people can enjoy games without compromise.
The Xbox Adaptive Controller, which is compatible with both Xbox and the PC, isn't your standard gamepad. It's a versatile hub designed to empower gamers with limited mobility. Instead of a fixed layout, it allows you to connect a variety of external switches, buttons, mounts and joysticks to create a completely customized controller that suits your needs and preferences. This approach lets you comfortably play your favorite games your way.
RIG Nacon Pro Compact Controller
Best for small hands
Product Specifications
Wireless: No | Weight: 7 oz | Mappable Buttons: Yes
Not everyone has hands suited for bulky controllers — and compared to other consoles, Xbox controllers are without a doubt the largest. If you prefer a more compact design, the RIG Nacon Pro Controller is a great alternative. This lightweight controller is excellent for gamers with smaller hands and those who prioritize comfort. Despite its size, the RIG Nacon Pro retains all the functionality of a standard Xbox controller.
Its companion app lets you set up customized button profiles and tweak thumbstick sensitivity. Plus, it includes a durable and generously long braided cable, ensuring you have enough room (10 feet) to move around comfortably without compromising your connection.
Given its affordability and mappable buttons, the RIG Nacon Pro is worth considering, especially if you prioritize comfort over flashy features.
Key considerations
You’ll find a wide array of Xbox One controllers on the market, and while it might take some time to find the one that fits your gaming style, here are some of the baseline features any worthwhile device should include:
- Wired connection option to your Xbox One console
- Indication of compatibility with all versions of the Xbox One console and PC
- 3.5-millimeter audio jack for headset
Design and comfort
Most Xbox One controllers share a similar design to the iconic and official Xbox wireless controller. However, there are a few exceptions, such as the Hyperkin Duke, which was modeled after the chunky original Xbox controller first seen in 2001.
Many Xbox wireless controllers mimic the ergonomic shape and overall design because the original fits most hands comfortably. Be on the lookout for controllers that feature textured, rubberized grips and swappable thumbsticks if you’re in the market for an especially comfortable Xbox One controller. Some thumbsticks are better for defensive gameplay; others are better for aggressive gameplay. This is due to a difference in height and texture. Plus, some thumbsticks are more comfortable or suitable for certain genres than others because of their grip texture.
Configuration
Although most players won’t even think about remapping the buttons to control their favorite games better or switch out controller pieces for a superior setup, there are premium Xbox One controllers that have hardcore fans covered. If you’re a dedicated Xbox One player or participate in esports, it’s worth investigating premium Xbox One controllers that have hair-trigger locks for quicker trigger presses, several D-pad options and extra buttons to which you can assign functions.
For example, the Razer Wolverine V2 Chroma has interchangeable thumbsticks and a hair-trigger mode with trigger-stop switches that allow for more speed or accuracy and the ability to button-mash with greater speed.
Xbox One controller features
While every official Xbox One controller can handle your favorite Xbox One games like a champ, some models have features and perks that other controllers don’t. Here are some top features to consider when comparing Xbox One controllers.
Mappable buttons
Some controllers allow you to customize the button layout. You might do this to make a specific game’s button commands quicker or more manageable. Most controllers with this feature allow you to save several profiles so you don’t need to constantly tweak them. You can often toggle between profiles on the fly so your gameplay isn’t interrupted.
Colors and patterns
While functionality is king when choosing a controller, colors and patterns can play a significant role in your decision. A controller’s pattern or color scheme can reflect a gamer’s personality or favorite franchise. Limited-edition controllers featuring unique colors or artwork can also be collector's items and conversation starters.
Xbox One controller prices
Inexpensive
If you need a bunch of controllers to entertain a party of players or a large family, there are plenty of cheaper wired Xbox One controllers out there. These budget devices might lack features like wireless play and vibration feedback, but you can pick one up for as little as $25 to $50.
Midrange
Since your Xbox One console included at least one Xbox wireless controller, you might want to buy another for couch-side co-op with a friend or to upgrade to a design that fits your taste. Microsoft’s default Xbox One controllers range in price due to the scarcity of designs and colors available, but you can easily find an Xbox wireless controller for $50 to $100. Note that some of the most common colors, like white and black, are often the most affordable.
Expensive
If you’re interested in buying an Xbox One controller with advanced button mapping, additional buttons, swappable thumbsticks and D-pads and other advanced extras, expect to spend a bit more for the experience. These premium Xbox One controllers cost between $100 and $180.
Tips
- Use your Xbox One controller without AA batteries by directly connecting it to your Xbox One. You’ll need a charging cable with a micro-USB connection on one end and a full-size USB connection on the other. Simply plug the micro-USB side into your controller and the USB side into your Xbox One. Now, you can forget about spending any more money on controller batteries.
- Improve the signal. If your Xbox One controller keeps dropping its wireless connection, move closer to the Xbox One console. Move any objects that might be interfering with the wireless signal, such as a laptop, cordless phone or microwave oven.
- Remap the buttons. Open the Xbox Accessories preinstalled on Xbox One S and Xbox One X consoles to remap the buttons on your Xbox One controller. Note that it’s important to keep the controls assigned to the A and B buttons. If you don’t, you won’t be able to use your Xbox One.
- Reset your Xbox One controller to its default factory settings. Simply open the Xbox Accessories app, select your controller, press Configure and select Restore Defaults.
- Turn on your Xbox One by pressing and holding the Xbox button on the controller. If the console is already on, this button prompt will simply turn on the controller.
How we tested and analyzed
We tested the best of the best pick in our lineup: Microsoft Xbox Core Wireless Controller. We unboxed the controller, set it up, analyzed its design and build and tested its functionality and features for performance. It impressed us in many categories, and we used the same baseline and testing reports to search for other high-quality Xbox controllers.
FAQ
Q. How do I update my Xbox One controller?
A. Microsoft regularly releases important controller improvements. If you believe your device needs the latest software update, follow these simple steps.
- Press the Xbox button to open the guide.
- Navigate to System, Kinect & Devices, Devices & Accessories and select your controller.
- From there, enter the Device info menu, choose the Firmware version and press Continue.
- Once you see the “Controller Updated” message, you’re good to go.
Q. How do I connect a wireless Xbox One controller to my Xbox One console for the first time?
A. It’s easier than you might think! Make sure your Xbox One controller has fresh batteries or a full charge, and then press and release the Connect button on your Xbox One console. The Connect button is below the console’s Power button, next to a trio of curved lines that look like radio waves.
Press and release the Connect button on your controller. The Xbox button in the center of your controller will flash for a few moments. You’ll know it has a secure connection to your console when the Xbox button stays illuminated.
Q. How do I adjust my Xbox One controller’s vibration settings?
A. Some people prefer to feel the rumble when their race car slams into a rival player while speeding at 100 miles per hour. Those who feel that a vibrating controller is a distraction can try the following.
- Press the “Xbox” button.
- Go to System, Settings, Ease of Access, Controller, and Vibration settings.
Note that some Xbox One controllers only have the option to toggle vibration on or off, while more advanced models allow you to fine-tune your feedback-vibration settings.
Q. How do Xbox One controllers compare to PlayStation 5 controllers?
A. The PlayStation 5 controller, the DualSense, boasts a significant design change over its predecessor, the DualShock 4. In fact, that redesign is far more significant than the changes seen between the Xbox Series X controller and the Xbox One controller.
The DualSense has a few features you won’t find on Xbox controllers. It utilizes haptic feedback, a technology that creates a captivating sense of touch to fully immerse you in your games. An integrated speaker creates an extra layer of depth and adaptive triggers that allow you to feel varying levels of force and tension as you interact with your in-game environments.
The Xbox controller sticks are asymmetrical, which some players find preferable for first-person shooters. Many gamers find the Xbox controller's ergonomics to be superior to those of the PS5. This is a major consideration for players who have limited mobility or want a comfortable controller for extended gaming sessions.
Q. Are third-party Xbox controllers better than official controllers?
A. Third-party Xbox controllers offer a tempting alternative to Microsoft's official options. While Microsoft controllers are known for their reliability, durability and overall quality, third-party options can be attractive for their programmable buttons, RGB lighting, cross-compatibility and unique designs.
Our expertise
With extensive experience in consumer electronics, particularly gaming consoles and accessories, I'm well-equipped to guide you toward the perfect Xbox controller. My background includes owning Xbox consoles across generations, allowing me to understand the evolution of controller design firsthand. This knowledge is further bolstered by reviewing countless gaming accessories, where I analyze performance reports and customer reviews to deliver top-tier product recommendations.
Beyond technical expertise from my tenure at BestReviews, I'm a passionate gamer myself. Whether it's diving into Xbox exclusives like Halo and Gears of War or tackling third-party titles like Call of Duty, Mortal Kombat, and Rainbow Six, I understand the importance of a controller that seamlessly complements your playstyle.
